The CJEU has ruled that a creditor’s claim for a lump-sum compensation for debt recovery costs may, in certain circumstances, constitute an abuse of rights. The judgement was handed down in a case concerning two Polish businesspeople who had an ongoing commercial relationship.
The case concerned an invoice that was paid five days after the due date. Despite the slight delay, the creditor, after just a few years, claimed 40 euros in compensation.
As Justyna Burska points out, when assessing such a claim, one cannot limit oneself solely to establishing that a delay occurred. The circumstances of the specific case are also relevant, including the conduct of the parties and the nature of their relationship. Merely meeting the formal criteria for claiming compensation does not, therefore, determine the validity of the claim.
The CJEU judgement does not call into question creditors’ right to compensation for debt recovery costs. It does, however, indicate that this right cannot be exercised in a manner contrary to its purpose.
We invite you to read the full article: LINK







